
Over a year into the administration's anti-immigration agenda, we’re seeing the economic fallout. For the first time in at least 50 years, estimates are that we lost immigrants on net; far fewer than usual arrived and a somewhat higher than usual number left. But if anyone benefited from that shift, it wasn’t U.S.-born workers. Even against the backdrop of our weak labor market, foreign-born workers now have slightly lower unemployment rates and higher labor market participation than they did two years ago. Their wages have also ticked up. Meanwhile, reduced population growth has thrown the country’s economic benchmarks into chaos, making it harder to interpret job creation, GDP, and the health of the labor market.
Chapters
Episode Details
- Published
- Oct 27, 2026
- Duration
- 41:21
- Episode Number
- Episode 31
- Listen On
- Podcast Platform
Immigration Economics Part II: Smaller is Worse
<!-- speaker-eval: pass verdict=ok confidence=high recommendation=none auto_swapped=false -->
Kathryn: Hello and welcome to Optimist Economy. I'm economist Kathryn Anne Edwards.
Robin: I'm editor Robin Rauzi.
Kathryn: On this show, we believe the U.S. economy can be better. And we talk about how to get there one problem and solution at a time.
Robin: This week we're going to talk about immigration. This is our second episode on immigration, but specifically we're going to look at what the economic data is showing us a year or more after the president's anti-immigration agenda went into full swing.
Kathryn: Yes, but first announcements.
Robin: Some announcements.
Kathryn: You should do yours first.
Robin: OK, so first I want to say thank you to a second anonymous donor for their Eternal Optimist size contribution came into us through our website at optimisteconomy.com that really is keeping us on the air. And we appreciate all the support we get from listeners.
Kathryn: And just a quick note about the opposite of support, how to fight your family at Thanksgiving. Send us your questions. What do you need help with? We'll do the homework, we'll answer them and give you the talking points you need to make it through dinner. And when I say make it through Thanksgiving dinner, what I really mean is win Thanksgiving dinner.
Robin: And do me a favor, when you send those by email, put Thanksgiving in the subject line. Don't do it in the comments. Don't do it in the — send it by email to optimist.economy@gmail.com that will help me a ton.
Kathryn: OK. OK, Retcon, what's yours?
Robin: Last week we talked about consumer sentiment and I realized there was this thing that you and I had talked about that we didn't get to in the episode, which was this idea about economic figures like GDP being essentially plutocratic versus consumer sentiment. The idea that the data that measures the economy in that world, the GDP world, $1 is one vote and that in the consumer sentiment world, one person is one vote. We had a lot of other things to talk about, but that was one of the things that stuck with me and I wanted to make sure we sort of put that out there because it put those two. The positive economic figures that we get from reported data and the consumer sentiment thing, kind of. While they seem to diverge, it explained the divergence to me.
Kathryn: Yeah, it's a really powerful notion that the economy is in no way democratic in the sense that, like, it's just total spending.
Robin: Yeah.
Kathryn: Not how much each person can afford, but how much we as a country consume. But it's not the same as you have 100 Americans buying something, here's how much they spend versus you have 100 Americans, and you ask them how they're feeling. It's easy to see where the divergences would come from when you have the type of incredible inequality that we have.
Robin: Yeah, I mean, rich people spending more money doesn't make middle class and working class people feel better about the economy.
Kathryn: You know, I actually had a comment on TikTok. Well, I did say this on Jon Stewart's podcast, but it like really delights me of, like, trickle down works. You just. You have to squeeze incredibly hard.
Robin: Yeah. Yeah.
Kathryn: Really get blood from that stone. Oh, you had another consumer sentiment Retcon.
Robin: Yes, I did. You're right. Last week I also said that the consumer sentiment numbers were 48.1. Now these, again, were just meaningless numbers. What did you say? Eleventy. Yeah. But in fact, in the window between when we recorded and now, the preliminary numbers for October came out and it was 46.3. Again, that's preliminary. One final thing is that we did get a comment on Apple Podcast reviews from a young person who's a new listener who was saying that they needed some sort of orientation to the issues, particularly around Social Security. So I just want you to know that on our website, we do have a starter kit, an Optimist Economy starter kit that includes the six most shared and recommended episodes from Season 1.
Kathryn: Yeah, we got a young person.
Robin: Yay. You've got a Retcon, too.
Kathryn: I do. So we did an episode about the accounts, which shall not be named. The child development accounts, child savings accounts, Trump accounts, 401 kids, 530A accounts. They're all the same thing. We need to come up with the name. But I think for the moment, they are the kid accounts, where you have basically an investment account opened up for every kid in the U.S. potentially. And what we stressed in the episode is that this whole endeavor will fail unless there's auto enrollment.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: Well, hold onto your hats, optimist. We just got auto enrollment. I heard that new guidance from Treasury has announced that there are accounts for every single kid in the U.S. So if you have a child under 18, they have an account. And you now will be starting to get instructions on how to claim the account. Now, there's still a lot.
Robin: There's a lot of stuff.
Kathryn: There's still a lot of stuff we don't understand, like what does it mean to claim the account? In theory, you have until the kid turns 18 to claim the account. So that means there's 70 million accounts right now. I think it's being held by the Bank of New York and they are taking the deposits. If you've got the $1,000 starter and you have until the kid is 18 to claim it, they just need to go basically like, we don't know what claim means, I guess is kind of the. There's an account, but what does it mean to access it? We're working on it, but I think this is. I wanted to stress a few things. One, this is awesome. I mean, this is just awesome that we are moving forward with wealth building that will challenge the type of wealth inequality we see because it's 70 million kids getting their own starter kit. There are so many more questions than answers right now. But getting auto enrollment, what did someone tell me last night when we were talking about it? It moved the ball from our end zone to the 5-yard line. Now, did I say that correctly? Knowing that I'm not a huge football fan, I feel like I got. I feel like I'm there. But he was like, you know, there are still lots of equity concerns. There are still lots of things that we want to check for, but we're there. And so am hopeful that despite the name, that when the Democrats are in power again and reasonable people are running our country, that they will claim ownership of these accounts because it is a longtime Democratic proposal that it will be moved into the future in the way that we want. The gist is, the reason we got auto enrollment was because of Michael Dell.
Robin: Oh yeah.
Kathryn: And the first basically year of voluntary enrollment, the number of people from low-income households that enrolled was like enough to round down to zero. And so the auto enrollment came from the people who don't want to give money to middle class and wealthy kids and were like, I'm not spending my donation trying to get people to open accounts. You need to do it. That opens up a whole other can of worms of like, who are they giving money to? And can like the donation money be kind of accelerating inequality? But it's like, this is the thing about inequality. It's a hydra. You cut off one head, you have to go for the next one. And so, like, the auto enrollment was, like, the biggest, worst head, and now we have to go for all the little ones. The separate announcement is that there was really some alarming news that possibly wealthy people could donate stock directly into the accounts, which would have some real ethical issues involved. So that is the next kind of battle. But I. I guess for the optimists, the fight continues, and we just had a really big victory.
Robin: Great. Terms and Conditions is our next chapter. We're now so far from my term, it doesn't matter anymore.
Kathryn: You should say it.
Robin: Okay. The term and condition that I have is plutocratic. Plutocratic means related to being governed by the wealthy. I didn't actually look this up because I didn't know what it meant, but I did think that, again, for our younger listeners, plutocratic. Good word to know. And it came up this week because of my aforementioned Retcon about economic figures being plutocratic.
Kathryn: I actually don't know if I knew what plutocratic meant. Like, if it's like autocratic plutocratic, it might have put them all in, like, the same kind of category of, like, bad, bad, bad. -cratic.
Robin: We're going to take a quick break where there will be probably no ad.
Kathryn: You know what? We're going to take a dramatic pause.
Robin: We're going to take a dramatic pause, and someday someone is going to put a sponsorship here. If you would like to find out about sponsoring this show, reach out. We'll tell you more.
Kathryn: OK, so we're back, and we are talking about immigration. Our prior episode on immigration, I tried to walk through what are the basic economics? And they're kind of easy because it's like, bigger is better.
Robin: I think that was the title of the episode.
Kathryn: Yeah, Bigger is Better. Today's episode is Smaller is Worse. What happens when we lose immigrants that should have arrived but didn't to the United States? And so that's what we're going to talk about now. This is actually our second attempt to try and record this episode. The first attempt, we made it halfway through, and we were so depressed and angry. And angry. We're like. And I'm optimistic. I don't know why. Like, there was just. It was a very tough episode. So we canned it, and we're like, we're going to come back, and we. We need to come up with a set of ground rules for what we're talking about.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: So there are two sides of the immigration narrative in the United States now, and probably for all of our history. The first is nativist, racist, hateful rhetoric about who belongs here, about what we look like or should look like. And this rhetoric is spilling directly into how immigration enforcement is being conducted, with raids and quotas and Americans being murdered on the street or in their car. That is all kind of of the same — like, when you condition people to hate and then you arm people to go find them, violence is the inevitable result. We're not going to talk about that because we can't talk about it without both depressing ourselves and punching a hole in the wall and getting so mad. What we want to talk to you about, Optimist, is the other side of the immigration story, which is the economic one — that we need to have protectionism for American workers and that immigrants take our jobs and they harm our economy and that our economy would be better off if immigrants weren't here. So companion lie to: we would have a better country if we were all, you know, blonde-haired WASPs — we would have a better economy if immigrants weren't here.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: We're going to talk about the second one.
Robin: Yeah, I do want to just note that, I mean, I think that in the 2024 election there was also both of those things as part of the debate, but there was also sort of just a general rule of law and control of the border that I think was almost the tipping point. So in other words, I do think there's a lot of racist stuff in the immigration debate, but I also think that there were some people who were absolutely swayed on this issue — but not because they were racist, because there was a lot of craziness at the border, particularly as the pandemic wound down. And also maybe, like, whether or not it's legitimate or not, a cost of public services to immigrants strand. But we're going to focus on the jobs and wages piece of this.
Kathryn: So the U.S. lost immigrants last year in 2025, and we are on track to lose immigrants again in 2026. Most of this loss does not come from deportation or even self-deportation. It is from the halted arrival of typical flows into the country that are being shut down. So one of the big ones was — I think it was spouses that are typically let in — you have all kinds of visa programs, all kinds of access to the United States via certain pipelines, and those are what are shutting down. And that is the biggest driver of having 2025 be the first year — I don't know how far it goes back — that we actually lost immigrants, right?
Robin: Yeah. And I mean this was just in the news this last week. The Trump administration had tried to add a $100,000 fee on H-1B visas. They've rekindled that fee in a new form. And they've also announced that they're basically shutting down the H-1B visa to green card pipeline for tech companies that they say are abusing it. So it's not just sort of shutting down the border. There's all these legal, long-term legal paths to immigration, which again, we can debate whether or not they have been good or bad or well managed. But anyway, those are also just being cranked shut, every one of those pipelines.
Kathryn: Yes. So the U.S. became simply a lot harder to reach in 2025.
Robin: Yeah. Maybe less desirable.
Kathryn: Maybe less desirable and similar in 2026. So what did this do? I mean, the argument that a protectionist anti-immigrant would make for the economics of not having immigrants is that this would be good for U.S. workers, that now we have fewer people competing for the jobs. So this is going to be to the benefit of U.S. workers. And that is absolutely not what has happened. What has happened is that it has been to the benefit of the immigrants who are still here. So the Census Bureau in various surveys ask about nativity and it's a residence and a birth question of like last year, did you live in this county? Did you live in the same county in a different state? Did you live in a different state? Did you live in a different country? And they'll also ask if you were born in the U.S. and your state of birth. And so from this we have very clear measures of nativity. We do not have clear measures of status.
Robin: By nativity you mean where someone was born?
Kathryn: Yes. OK, so we don't know their citizenship. Right. Because half of immigrants are U.S. citizens or more than half. So you could come from another country, become a citizen, and so you are still an immigrant, but you're an immigrant citizen. That's about half of immigrants. So we don't know if they're a citizen. All we know is whether or not they were born here. The decline in immigration is benefiting the immigrants that are still here.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: And they have less unemployment and they have higher employment and they even have higher wage growth because the labor market is segregated in so many ways between the jobs that men and women do, between the jobs that native-born and foreign-born workers do. And getting rid of immigrants or having a reduction in immigrants didn't suddenly make a lot of native-born workers take those jobs. It really just took a labor pool for a set of occupations and made it smaller so those workers are, they're benefiting. And most of the gains to a decline in immigration have gone to the immigrant population.
Robin: Could this be because people who were here as immigrants and who weren't working or who didn't have good jobs left and that the people who are left in this pool just represent a higher number of people who are employed? Does that make sense?
Kathryn: Like cream skimming?
Robin: Yeah. You've taken out people from the survey pool who are less likely to have jobs or likely to have the lower paying jobs.
Kathryn: Yeah. So is this a composition effect? Like are these benefits that are accruing to foreign born workers? Is that because the pool of who is foreign born and still here is different? I would argue no, because their unemployment rate has gone down.
Robin: Yeah. Again, I think my question would be is that composition effect? Yeah, yeah.
Kathryn: The composition effect would be harder to square with a falling unemployment rate because the unemployment rate is only capturing people who want to work. So if you lost a lot of foreign born people who weren't working, that would be like how would the U.S. unemployment rate be changed if 10 million retirees moved to Costa Rica? It wouldn't be changed at all because they're not included in the calculation. They're not in the denominator. You have to be looking for work. So the decline in the unemployment rates is probably the clearest indicator that it's not a composition effect.
Robin: Okay.
Kathryn: So the biggest takeaway is the economy is slowing down, the labor market is slowing down, but the bright spots in the labor market in terms of populations that are doing OK are in fact foreign born.
Robin: I still don't know if I understand the mechanics of why it is that, you know, like you were saying, immigrants, when they leave, American born workers don't necessarily take those jobs. Assuming somebody's filling those jobs. They're also still going to immigrants. Give any sense of the mechanisms that are at work with that?
Kathryn: Oh yeah, there's a ton. It applies to so many parts of our labor market, not just native versus foreign born like you can imagine. I always say foreign burn. Foreign burn.
Robin: Getting real Texan there.
Kathryn: Foreign born immigrants. Yeah. So the foreign born. God. OK, hold on. Foreign born.
Robin: A little British there.
Kathryn: I really gotta put in the effort. So that's because workers aren't perfectly fluid across occupations in either their preferences or their skills. So what does that mean? I don't want to take any job there is. I have a preference over the job that I want to take. I'm not qualified for every job that there is. There are certain things I can do and certain things that I can't. And the mobility across occupations in the U.S. is not super high.
Robin: People don't necessarily very often switch from sales to construction.
Kathryn: Right. Because we're not cogs in the machine. I mean, I know we're all little worker bots, but we actually are still humans underneath. And we have preferences over the jobs we take. We have networks that get us into jobs.
Robin: Yeah, that's the thing. I wouldn't think that those preferences necessarily would align with country of origin. Right.
Kathryn: Or, you know. Okay, yes. So I think preferences, skills, networks.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: All three of these. So like, you know, if I were thinking about this like a heartless economist who has some worker bot. I drop someone into the economy and they should just go wherever they can get the highest wage. That is what makes sense in an economic model of I will always go to whatever job will give me the highest wage. So why doesn't that happen? That should happen. I should just. If there is a job that will pay 2 cents more, I should go take it. Right. It's always workers sort to the highest wage job they can get. What gets in the way of someone not taking the highest paid job they can get?
Robin: Well, they don't like it.
Kathryn: They don't like it. Yeah, that's one. That's one that I think we can all empathize with. Of like, sure, I could sell my soul and go become some, I don't want to say a profession in case one of the listeners is something that you wouldn't like. Yeah, something you wouldn't like. They could pay me more, but I wouldn't like it or I'm not qualified for that job or not suited for it. It has a skill set that I don't have or I don't want to have. It kind of mixes with preferences of both what I can do and what I want to do at a job or I just don't know about it. And all three of those will result in occupational sorting is what we call it, where different groups within the labor market tend to cluster in specific jobs. And it's easiest to see with men and women.
Robin: Sure.
Kathryn: That there are men jobs and there are women jobs. Not because we assign them that way, because they tend to tend to just end up that way because of preferences and skills and networks and networks is one that's really fascinating because I mean the estimates vary because the survey data isn't as good. But I mean, I've seen it as low as one-third but as high as two-thirds of. How did you get this job? And they say through a friend.
Robin: Yeah.
Kathryn: Where your network matters incredibly for the types of jobs that you are exposed to. And a lot of times this is studied in relation to economic mobility that you have like really high achieving kids who just don't know what are the elite jobs to apply for because it's their parents network that ends up influencing what they do or their parents profession. So the fourth one that's in there that's kind of blended with network is knowledge. So it's like preference skills, network knowledge. How do you end up in the job you have?
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: Well, all of those will be true for men and women, but they're also going to be true for native born and foreign born.
Robin: Right, right. So I'm a roofer and I'm from Central America and we need more roofers. And so I talk to people in my neighborhood or I talk to people in my church or I talk to people that my family knows and some more people from my community are in that. Drawn into that profession.
Kathryn: Yes.
Robin: OK.
Kathryn: So the big economic effect I think is the like foreign born workers are benefiting from the decrease in their supply.
Robin: Right. So where are we, where do we see that and how do we know it?
Kathryn: Well, so we see that in their unemployment rate and their employment rate and their wages. It's a market, you're reducing supply, it increases. It's not enough for demand and so the wages go up, up.
Robin: Do we see it at any granular gra. You can't say foreign born. I can't say granular.
Kathryn: Granular. Foreign born level. Foreign born. GR get granular with the foreign born.
Robin: I mean I just feel like what I read about where they're really feeling the loss of immigrant workers are agriculture, of course, healthcare and construction... and child care. Child care.
Kathryn: … and child care. So the other way that we can see the effect on the economy is that we are seeing occupation specific shortages. Child care workers, construction workers, healthcare support and tech jobs, agricultural work, all of those would have occupation specific shortages because they were immigrant dominant occupations.
Robin: Immigrant dominant. Does that mean majority immigrant?
Kathryn: They don't have to be. Not necessarily majority, but a concentration of foreign born in the occupation or in the specific field. If you want to think of it that way.
Robin: Sure. So what are you seeing on the wage side?
Kathryn: So the wage side, let me pull up the exact number. We can estimate the wage gap. We do this all kinds of ways. The average Black wages as a share of average white wages. White women wages as a share of white male wages, women as a share of men. Right? Where you have this concept of someone's earning a whole dollar and people are earning some percentage of it, gender wage gap, racial wage gap, and so on. So we do have a foreign born wage gap. And if you don't control for like occupation or anything like that and make it a sophisticated comparison, the gap had a big jump towards closing in 2025. So in 2024, just if you look at the earnings of foreign born workers as a percent of native born workers, it was 84 cents on the dollar, 84.1 to be specific. Just a year later it was 85.7.
Robin: And that's a big change in one year.
Kathryn: That's a pretty significant change for one year. Now it's a small population, you're making an estimate like they can move around. And you know the upshot there is that foreign-born workers still make less on average than native-born workers. It's just that the percentage between them dropped. And part of that is because the wages of foreign-born workers got improved relative to native-born. Because the overall labor market story that's going on in the background is that our labor market is getting weaker and it's been getting weaker since the summer of 2022. So the backdrop of all of this is not a booming labor market, but rather kind of a busting one.
Robin: Is that also, I mean, what's keeping workers born in the U.S. from filling these jobs?
Kathryn: Well, I mean they're the same thing. Skills, preferences, network knowledge. Right. If we just do. And then there's the friction. The friction is something that like any time between you lose a job and you start another one, anything in between would be a friction. We would think of it as like search friction, like you can only apply for so many jobs in a day or you have to find a job that matches. Unemployment is associated with a lot of frictions. So do you want the job? Can you do the job? Do you know about the job and then how do you find that job? All of those are part of the labor market, like it's just all the time. But we don't really normally have this type of labor market experience where we just get rid of a very small set of people and then see what happens.
Robin: I mean, I guess the reason I'm asking this is not if that was the promise or that was the political campaign rhetoric that we're going to push these people out of this country and therefore out of the labor market and this is going to create more jobs. Was this ever going to work? Is there some sort of way that it was that, that in an ideal world it would have worked?
Kathryn: Well, it's a double hit because bigger is better. So if we're missing people, we're missing part of the economy. And if we're missing a million people, then we're missing a million people's consumption, which means we're missing a million people's contribution to the size of the economy overall. That's a lot of growth to lose. And then the second hit is that because of the composition of our labor market and how people end up in the jobs and occupations that they end up in, you're also getting hit in that like we were willing to lose part of our economy in order to like reallocate workers into some jobs. We lost part of the economy. We don't have the reallocation because that's not how people work. It's like a double hit. Over the next 15 years, there will be hundreds of papers on what is going on in the labor market right now and what is going on in households that have immigrants in mixed-status households. What happened to their labor force participation, why there were occupational shortages. I mean, I like to think of economics research often as detective work for things like this where like this is the case and they'll spend a decade solving it and we'll learn all kinds of new things about workers and preferences and skills and networks and all of that. But the overall story is the one, the big markers are the ones we see first. And the big markers are showing us that we made our economy smaller because we lost people. And it was not to the benefit of native-born workers. Because the labor market doesn't really see, it's not really like that. The labor market doesn't divide people up by their gender or their nativity. It really just divides them up by their skills and the jobs they have. And so this like cross-cut of like foreign-born, it just didn't make any sense to the degree that like, like treating people like that would never make any sense.
Robin: But yeah, it's interesting. I mean, what, I don't know, what you just said seemed a little bit in conflict with the idea that there actually are these separate pools of workers.
Kathryn: But it's like it's not top down, it's bottom up, right? Like I don't assign people to jobs and I don't have native jobs and foreign-born jobs. And then men jobs and women jobs and white jobs and Black jobs. Like there's no one like sorting people and assigning them to roles. That is just like, you know, technical economics term. That's just how the cookie crumbles. When you have a lot of people that look different and live in different places and have different experiences and like out they go in the world. And the notion of anti-immigration being a successful economic policy for a certain set of people, you'd have to be sorting. And we don't like, we don't have that type of autocratic control over the labor market.
Robin: Right.
Kathryn: So of course it was going to backfire in your face. Like, I, I don't know, I just, it's.
Robin: Yeah, okay.
Kathryn: I'm trying to not cuss too much because last time that was part of what got us to the bad place was, was our like, why don't I just let my anger out?
Robin: Right, right.
Kathryn: Well, the points I really wanted to make, I think I made, which were smaller is worse. And people are people, not cogs in a machine as much as economists would probably love that. And that complicates this story and shows just how ignorant this type of policy is on some level. But I think the other part of it is it is happening at a really, really specific time in our labor market that is historically bad. And the consequences of what is going on are not just limited to the economy is smaller and also that foreign born have kind of benefited from being in sudden short supply. It is also making it harder for us to interpret our economy because everything in our economy is a moving target.
Robin: Sure.
Kathryn: Think of it as like the balloon that's kind of slowly filling with air. And every benchmark we have is relative to how quickly that air is filling. So how many jobs do we need to add in a month? How fast should our economy be growing? All of these things are predicated on population size. On some basic level, our economy is a reflection of the number of people in it. Well, when you start attacking that, it is very unclear how to interpret whether our economy is hitting marks.
Robin: The benchmarks are just useless now.
Kathryn: Yeah, yeah, the benchmarks are totally useless. So I know in the sentiment episode, I mean, I know that your first thing is going to be to think is like, it's not hitting marks. My life sucks. Or my, you know, I can't afford how. Like I know those benchmarks. I mean like even the macro benchmarks of what we need to hit, those also get really hard to interpret.
Robin: Yeah. Did you look at that — was it Dallas Fed or St. Louis Fed story, report or blog post about how many jobs we need to add? It had these estimates of what they thought was even happening with the levels of immigration. And you know, it's just, we just don't even know. And not just because of whether or not the government wants to report it. Like, if you're here on a green card and you decide to move away, there's no requirement that you tell the government that you left. Right. We have no idea. And so, you know, you're trying to find what the benchmark should be in terms of — all right, how many jobs do we need to add for the growing population? We don't even know.
Kathryn: Yeah, in, in the era we're in, it's really easy to like write that off of like, it doesn't even matter what jobs you add because I still can't afford this or I'm having trouble with this. But it does matter because the cascading consequences of losing confidence in the economy, you know, this goes back to the consumer sentiment of like, where do you think we're going to be in a year? Well, if you tell me we add 25,000 jobs, where I think we'll be in a year really depends on whether or not I think that that number is hitting the mark or not. The short answer is nobody knows how many jobs we need to be adding because we don't know what our population is doing because we're attacking our population growth.
Robin: We also don't know how many people are being arrested, detained and deported. And by the way, shout out to the Deportation Data Project based partly here at UCLA in Los Angeles. They're doing Freedom of Information Act data requests constantly to try to find out what's actually been happening on the forcing people out of the country side of this question and really doing God's work on that.
Kathryn: It feels like so heartless to reduce this back to the economy, but it has an economic effect. I mean, I think a lot of people would be under the impression like, I'm native born, I kept my job. And so sure, like they're messing with the foreign born population, but that's not going to affect me. It absolutely affects you that we are attacking our source of population growth. We're risking so much. The economy being smaller hurts you. Jobs going unfilled hurts you. The economy's strength moving into obscurity on some level that also hurts you. It should be obvious, but it's actually really hard to systematically attack a part of our economy and end up better off. The last one I'll add about what's at risk here is Social Security needs workers too. The current depletion date is the fall of 2032. But that depletion date is an estimate that has to take into account things like birth and death and wages and so on. And their population estimates, they basically account for the fact that we lost people in 2025 but didn't project it into the future. Yeah, no, they go right back to, we get a million more people a year, and that's not going to accelerate it by, like, two years. But, I mean, that will keep pushing up the depletion dates because Social Security needs workers, and we're dealing with a smaller economy and smaller labor market. When you don't let certain people in. A smaller economy hurts Social Security. I don't want this to sound like. Because I love Social Security so much, I'm like, give me, like, gourmet people. I need bodies like Social Security needs bodies. But I think Social Security is a really easy way to see how, like, the harm of having fewer people here in making our economy smaller. Like, Social Security for almost everything. It's just a mirror. It's just reflecting our overall economy back to us.
Robin: Is there anything you're optimistic about here?
Kathryn: I realize that this might be an ephemeral victory and maybe one that doesn't last, but one theme of this administration is that they really take the boogeyman of rhetoric and put it into practice, and we are left to collect the data. I think there's something to be said for the next time this rhetoric comes up of like, hey, this is better for Americans if we attack immigrants or if we don't have as many immigrants, you can say like, no, it is not. You saw what happened in '25 and '26. It's not like there was some miracle cure from having fewer immigrants. Like, it was a terrible economic time, in part because you were getting rid of immigrants, and they were the ones that benefited. Like, I think being able to. This was such a clear economic case to me. But sometimes experiencing this bad economic case is helpful for talking about in the future. Like, you. You know, what are you gonna get? A different outcome. The same. You're into the same thing. Like, this hurts the economy. We told you it hurts the economy, and now we have proof it hurts the economy. I mean, same thing with, you know, kind of similar vein with something like tariffs.
Robin: Yeah, yeah.
Kathryn: Like, we told you it would hurt the economy and increase prices. And, like, what do you know? It hurt the economy and increase prices.
Robin: I know. And we're spend. I mean, the amount of money we're spending on this enforcement is also just staggering. I mean, they're going to hire another 5,000 ICE agents or employees, I guess. Yeah.
Kathryn: I wrote a newsletter about this where I compare the amount of spending that goes to immigration enforcement from the One Big Beautiful Bill Act versus social welfare spending. I mean, I think that one, it pisses me off to such an incredible degree, but I can't actually fault immigration enforcement for that because Congress makes terrible choices. It's like, this is not the economics of immigration type of argument. This is just like, yeah, we have a terrible Congress and they make terrible choices all the time. And it's not as if we were suddenly no longer nativist and convinced that immigrants are what's holding us back economically, that we would suddenly spend more on children. Like, it's not like that money was going to go somewhere good in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. So I think.
Robin: Fair enough.
Kathryn: That part I.
Robin: Fair enough.
Kathryn: Yeah. That one's not like a direct trade off. Like, it's a whole other problem that Congress is bad at its job. And this is just the latest manifestation of it. Whereas, like, the separate case of the economics of immigration is kind of wound up.
Robin: All right, are we ready to take a break?
Kathryn: Are we ready to take a dramatic pause?
Robin: All right, we'll be back in a second. All right, we're back. My executive order is that if you read a news story, you are not allowed to then go in the comments and say, why hasn't the media been covering this issue? I read so many stories about immigration where that's exactly what people responded to, and including stories that were specifically pointing out how Mark Wayne Mullins had changed the strategy around enforcement. And therefore they weren't doing big raids in cities. And they were instead, you know, sort of fanning out across the country and just operating on slightly smaller scales, but everywhere, all at once. And The New York Times has done some great coverage on this. And then people would read the story and say, why isn't the news media covering this?
Kathryn: I've definitely been guilty of that before, though, on ones of my social channels especially, it was about immigration. I was like, no one's talking about this. Cause I was just like, mad. And I made a video. And then afterwards I was like, heard people were talking about this and I was being an. So I've done this. Your EO is me. All right, so, okay, my executive order, this one is, like, much more whimsical. But we have talked before about my love of independent bookstores. I'm here in Tulsa right now recording, and they have a delightful independent bookstore just around the corner called Magic City Books, and it is one of the best arrays of bookstore tote bags I have ever seen.
Robin: Great.
Kathryn: Part of me was like, you know, it would be really fun if we did a best of award, but just for, like, bookstore tote bags, like, this is the punniest. This is the one that speaks to reader's soul. I would love to have more celebration of readers and, like, for everybody. Every fifth story about how no one reads anymore. Like, let's lift up some bookstores. I would like to do something like that.
Robin: Great, great spiritual sponsors. These are the things that are kind of keeping us going through, you know, weeks, months, administrations. My spiritual sponsor, I was away from Los Angeles for four weeks, and when you come back, you really realize the things that you missed. And I'm going to say Sonora Town, which is one of the greatest Mexican restaurants in Los Angeles, and if you're from here, you know it, that they have the best flour tortillas anywhere in the city. So, yeah, Sonora Town kept me going this week.
Kathryn: My spiritual sponsor is a beer on tap. Because when you really need one and then you get one, it's awesome.
Robin: It's the best.
Kathryn: It is absolutely the best. I was at a restaurant last night. I'm at a conference, and, you know, even I get tired of talking.
Robin: What?
Kathryn: And interfacing. I know. And I. I still have to take some little, like, introvert healing time. And so at the end of this conference, a very long day of talking and interfacing and being charming, I went to a restaurant and I told the guy, I was like, I would like a beer on tap. And he's like, sure. I was like, the bitterest one you have. Like, just give me a real nasty IPA. And he was like, oh, my God, hold on. Wait one second. And then he left, and he came back with, like, what looked like a tray of shot glasses, but was actually, like, flight. Yes. It was like, four of the beers that they had on tap. And he was like, I don't drink beer, and I didn't want to mess this up. And so then he gave me, like, each of the four and had me try it. And he was like, great. And I was like, this is amazing. And then I sat in silence and read a book while sipping a very good beer. So that is my spiritual sponsor is that great beer on tap when you need it.
Robin: The Optimist Economy podcast is edited by Sofi LaLonde, and our video production for social media is by Andy Robinson. We're going to snap them out. Video clips from the show, which you can share, are available on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook and YouTube, and occasionally LinkedIn. We have our hats, our popular Optimist Economy caps, back in stock. There are still T-shirts and tote bags. I think we're down to the last three tote bags. Those are all available again on our website, optimisteconomy.com.
Kathryn: If you are on Substack, free or paid subscribers to Optimist Economy can join our chat. And if you have the means to contribute at whatever level you feel comfortable, we'll take your gift at optimisteconomy.com. The show is run entirely by your contributions and we are extremely grateful for them.



