Optimist Economy
Back to All Episodes
Episode 30Oct 20, 2026•48:19

Americans Feel Awful About the Economy

Share
Americans Feel Awful About the Economy - Optimist Economy Podcast Episode Cover

The Consumer Sentiment Index has tracked how Americans experience the U.S. economy through bouts of runaway inflation, a mortgage crisis, stock market bubbles, and six recessions. And yet the scores right now are lower than at any of those moments. After nearly 50 years of tracking by the University of Michigan, Consumer Sentiment has broken through the basement. Beneath the five index questions are some clues as to why: Since 2008, the number of people who say the government is doing a poor job has grown from about a third to about three-quarters. This dissatisfaction has been a slow burn — and it’s also evidence that Americans are ready for bold, non-incremental economic change. 0:00 — Opening 6:25 — Retcon: Vacation Days & Moral Hazard in Healthcare 11:18 — Terms & Conditions: Likert Scale 14:24 — The Big Pilcrow: What’s Consumer Sentiment Telling Us? 17:20 — Record Lows: Sentiment Breaks From the Other Economic Metrics 20:54 — The Five Index Questions: Take Consumer Sentiment Survey Yourself! 26:55 — How’s the Government Doing Managing the Economy? Survey says…Poor 29:39 — It's the Economy, Stupid 31:16 — Partisanship Cancels Itself Out 33:11 — Why This Isn't the Same as What Happened to Biden 35:25 — Who Does Feel Good? 36:07 — Low Sentiment Deserves Big Policy 38:07 — Executive Orders: Hold the reservation. Too many eggs.  41:52 — Spiritual Sponsors: So, so many 47:17 — Credits We’re making Thanksgiving plans. Got a dinner table debate we can help with? Send it to optimist.economy@gmail.com (and put Thanksgiving in the subject line).

Chapters

Episode Details

Published
Oct 20, 2026
Duration
48:19
Episode Number
Episode 30

Transcript

8,849 words · ~45 min read

Search all transcripts

Americans Feel Awful About the Economy

<!-- speaker-eval: pass verdict=ok confidence=high recommendation=none auto_swapped=false issues=Speaker B labels remapped to Robin (intro used “I’m Robin Rauzi / I’m an editor” instead of “I’m editor Robin”) -->

Kathryn: Hello and welcome to Optimist Economy. I'm economist Kathryn Anne Edwards.

Robin: I am not Jon Stewart. I'm Robin Rauzi and I'm an editor on this show.

Kathryn: We believe the U.S. economy can be better and we talk about how to get there one problem and solution at a time. And we're back.

Robin: We are back from break. And if you're new here because you saw Kathryn on that show with that guy. I'm not that guy. And I'm sorry, but I'm not. The Weekly Show.

Kathryn: The Weekly Show.

Robin: Today on Optimist Economy, we're going to talk about consumer sentiment, why people feel so bad when the economy supposedly looks good. And what does that mean and why is that happening? Also, what does it possibly mean for some midterm elections coming.

Kathryn: Yeah. Yeah. The headline announcement is that we are back from break that Robin actually took the vacation advice that we gave at the end of the last show, which is awesome, and took a significant vacation, a multiweek vacation.

Robin: Everyone should take a multiweek vacation. And I go back to my assertion that three weeks is the ideal length of a vacation. My trip was four and it was too long.

Kathryn: OK, quick announcements before we get underway. Thanksgiving is around the corner and last year we did a prep show where Robin assumed the voice of various hostile and conservative family members. And I answered their aggressive questions with even more aggressive answers. A few, few of these answers did go viral on the internet. At least one for the right reason. So we're taking those questions. What is the prep? What is the help you need? What is we are here for Thanksgiving and we will do another Thanksgiving episode.

Robin: Yeah, I just want to be clear that we're saying you should send us what you think you will be facing at your Thanksgiving table or over the holidays and we will address your concerns specifically as opposed to sort of making them up the way we did last year.

Kathryn: Yeah. So, for example, what do I say to my uncle who thinks Social Security is a Ponzi scheme?

Robin: That's right. We need 16 Social Security questions, so if you have those, please hit us with those.

Kathryn: That's great. I mean, last year. Last year, we just made up the questions. And so they were a solid half for Social Security before Robin got there and was like, maybe we don't need all of these. Send in your Thanksgiving questions. Other announcement. We featured this on our socials when we announced that we were coming back. But, Robin, you didn't by any chance run into a listener while you were on your travels, did you?

Robin: I did. Well, no, accurately. He ran into me. I went to a podcast conference while we were on break, and an Optimist listener apparently walked past me on the street. I was having lunch on an outdoor table and thought it looked like me, and then walked further and saw a bunch of people wearing podcast convention lanyards and said, no, that really might be her, and came back and said, are you Robin? And I immediately accused our video producer, Andy Robinson, of planting that guy, but it turned out that, no, he was a real person. And, yeah, well done. Well spotted in the wild, sir.

Kathryn: OK, I. I also ran into an Optimist at a Houston Dash game, and it's actually an Optimist I've seen before, only this time I was so socially awkward, I actually went home and, like, a wash of self-loathing. So I just happened to run into the. Yeah, no, no, I ran into this guy. So nice. I'm pretty sure he was there with his family, and he's like, hey, Optimist. And then he said something, like, about being on break, and just, like, words fell out of my mouth. I was like, yeah, a lot of people followed me on Instagram because the day that he ran into me, I had, like, a spate of celebrity follows come in. So it was like Ben McKenzie, aka Dreamy McKenzie from The O.C. Noah Wyle, Dr. Robbie himself.

Robin: Dr. Robbie.

Kathryn: OK. Bob Odenkirk. All of these people followed me within, like, two days of each other. And I'm at a soccer game by myself. I've not been at work or talking to humans. And he's like, hey, what are you doing? I was like, just busy being followed. Oh, my God, you couldn't. Afterwards, I was like, you are a massive Kathryn. And I went up to the upper deck to sit by myself. I was like, that is it Ben Affleck meme of like sad on a bench where I was just sitting there, like with the beer, just like absolutely questioning every decision I've ever made in life, which I'm sure a lot of people can empathize with. When you have an awkward social interaction, like, it's like your degree of self-loathing afterwards is totally disproportional to what you actually did. The guy was probably like, oh, weird, whatever. I even went home. My husband was like, how was the game? I'm like, I don't know. I know one part was bad. Oh, it's just. So anyway, that guy, fellow Dash fan. I'm so sorry. I'm not proud of myself. And next time come up and I promise I'm going to say something normal. I've been practicing for weeks.

Robin: You were practicing. I've got it like in my hand.

Kathryn: I am ready. How about those Dash? Like, I'm so ready to be a normal person if you run into me. And that was. Anyway, thank you. If he still listens. Yoink. That was bad.

Robin: Okay, one last thing. I want to give a big thank you to our contributor Dhruv, who's from the Bay Area of California. He made a generous contribution to Optimist Economy just about the time we went on break. And so I'm sorry it's taken us so long to thank you. And we also have an anonymous eternal optimist, but we know who he is. And thank you to you too, sir.

Kathryn: Okay, so if you're new here, if you're new here, we like to start the show with Retcon — retroactive continuity — where we talk about past episodes. Hopefully not just mistakes we've made, but often mistakes we've made. So yeah, so for example, that whole thing about how I don't know how to speak to humans in real life, that could have been a Retcon, possibly. That was a life Retcon.

Robin: Sure.

Kathryn: A listener Retcon. Our last episode was about vacation and why Americans should take more time off and.

Robin: And why they don't.

Kathryn: And why they don't. And one of the things we didn't bring up but that a woman wrote to me to say was parents will ration paid time off because of childcare instability. And we didn't talk about that over the course of the show, but that is another really good point. Childcare is really living in a very different version of itself than before the pandemic. And the number of people who report being out of work because their childcare center is closed or not available, that has gone up considerably in the years since, and it stayed elevated afterwards. And this can happen not just because your kid is sick, but also something like you could be ratioed where you have to have a specific number of adults per children in the room.

Robin: Oh, you mean in the childcare center?

Kathryn: Legally, they are not supposed to watch the kids with not enough staff, so enough people call in sick or enough people don't show up. And if they're really tightly staffed, this can happen a lot.

Robin: We got a similar letter that said another reason that people don't take vacation is that they're storing it as essentially their own personal unemployment insurance in case they lose their job as a way to extend their financial cushion, which I think also makes total sense.

Kathryn: Yeah, makes total sense. But we did get a lot of really fun emails after that. One of people saying, like, yeah, we should take vacation. And I got some DMs through the optimist chat of like, I'm on vacation. I was like, great, we love that. Go on vacation. The other Retcon we got was that we got what I think is our first one-star review.

Robin: Oh, it's our second. We got one very early on. Yeah.

Kathryn: OK. We got a one-star review. And it was because the health episode where I said, we need universal public health insurance, we don't understand the intricacies of supply and demand, and that without co-pays, people won't have the incentive to take care of themselves. So one star.

Robin: You know what? I like it. It took the edge off. It was like, you know what? You knew it was gonna come.

Kathryn: The pressure's off. Right. We had so many five-star reviews, so we had to let somebody down at some point. And I'm happy to do it over health insurance, frankly. We kind of talked about this in the episode, but the idea is that if you don't make people pay for their health, then they will treat themselves poorly because they're not on the hook financially for the consequences of their health. And this is called moral hazard. The only reason I brought this up is that I wanted you all to know that I thought the optimist would delight out of this story. I don't know if Robin's heard it. I was a research assistant in D.C. when the Affordable Care Act was passed.

Robin: Sure.

Kathryn: And this was a very common conservative talking point at the time of, if everyone has health insurance and we have to pay, you're just going to have moral hazard. People are going to abuse themselves and they won't take care of themselves because the taxpayers will pay for them.

Robin: So they won't take care of themselves because. I'm sorry. Because everyone loves going to urgent care.

Kathryn: Yes. It's a ridiculous argument. The idea that the reason why people aren't healthy would change if they had a co-pay versus not is really exceptional. I mean, maybe there would be some marginal health behaviors, but, like, do you break your leg if you have better health insurance? Like, nobody wants to break their leg. The idea is that it would foster risky behavior because the penalty for that behavior wouldn't financially be upon you, even though the penalty of worse health and you feeling bad would be upon you. As if the only penalty for having bad health is the money and not actually having bad health. So in honor of this argument, the night that the Affordable Care Act was being debated and passed, I threw a moral hazard party. And I invited a bunch of people over to my house that I lived in, like, a group house with, like, four roommates. And we only served alcohol, donuts, and cigarettes. I didn't even smoke. Like, I didn't. I don't like smoking, but I smoked that night because I was like, baby, we got health insurance. Let's smoke. And I sent a picture to my boss holding. She was a health economist holding, like, a cigarette and a donut. And I was like, it passed. I have just been a smart ass for as long as I can remember. But yeah. So just as a reminder, when we get universal public health insurance, cigarettes are on me.

Robin: Our next chapter is called Terms and Conditions. Kathryn, it looks like you looked something up. I didn't look anything up this week. But what did you look up — or you probably didn't look it up — what are you going to explain to us?

Kathryn: I did have to look it up. I knew about the one part, but not the other. So the Likert scale, if you've ever taken any type of survey or form, you have filled out an answer with a Likert scale. It's something like, do you strongly agree, agree, neither disagree or agree, strongly disagree. And so on. And it gives you a range of responses for some type of, like, somewhat nebulous feeling. So rarely. Often rarely. Sometimes, often, never. Yeah, like, that's.

Robin: I did one today for Southwest Airlines.

Kathryn: Yeah, yeah, that's a Likert scale. So I looked up who Likert was. Likert was a man. His first name was Rensis. So he was Rensis Likert.

Robin: OK.

Kathryn: He was an engineer. And he switched from engineering to psychology. He worked for the Bureau of Agricultural Economics. And he also worked for some really, like, disturbingly named office during World War II, like the Office of Bombing Morale, something like that. Anyway, when the war ended, they had this big group of psychological researchers in the government. Congress shut down their funding, and they all moved to the University of Michigan together, and they set up what became the Institute for Social Research, which is a powerhouse of a research institution that produces many surveys, including the Survey of Consumers, which is where we get the Consumer Sentiment Index, something that they did for the first time in the '40s. So Rensis Likert, the engineer psychologist who came up with survey responses on a scale, was the founder of kind of this powerhouse research institute. OK. That is what I looked up in reference to our centerpiece discussion, the Biggest Pilcrow.

Robin: You know, we did get a — I should have said this in Retcon. I'm going to Retcon. Retcon in the middle of the episode.

Kathryn: This is what I've always wanted for Robin to Retcon. Retcon.

Robin: We did get an email from a graphic designer who said it just sets his teeth on edge the way that we use the word pilgrim.

Kathryn: Really?

Robin: Yeah, because it is an inverted typographical symbol. It's not, you know, sorry, dude. I am sorry. Sorry.

Kathryn: Yeah, I guess if — assuming that maybe we have new listeners, one of our Terms and Conditions in the first season was a pilcrow, which is the backwards P that has two lines that, you know, indicates the beginning of a new paragraph and historically a new idea, which is our nickname for the main section of our discussion, the Big Pilcrow. And we'll have to — sorry again to that guy, because people really, we — they really love it. The Biggest Pilcrow. OK, before we get to the Big Pilcrow, we'll take a quick break, and maybe there will be an ad in between. We don't know. But then we'll stop and we'll come back. There'll be a pause. At the very least, dramatic, dramatic pause. And then we'll come back.

Robin: And we're back.

Kathryn: We're back to talk about how you feel about the economy, which is not good, apparently, statistically.

Robin: Statistically speaking, it's not good.

Kathryn: Not good.

Robin: I have some questions about this. Kathryn Anne Edwards and I had a brief call. I was still on vacation, but I was recalling that there are multiple measures of consumers or multiple surveys. I wondered if, just to start, if you could explain which one you're talking about and how it differs a little bit from the other, other ones that people might read about in the news.

Kathryn: So all of these are going to have a very similar vibe, which is a gauge of how Americans feel about the economy. The Consumer Sentiment Index is the one produced by the University of Michigan, which is the one we are going to talk about, and it's the one economists greatly prefer. It's an older series. I'm pretty sure it's an older series.

Robin: An older series, just meaning it started earlier.

Kathryn: Yeah, it goes back to, like, in the '40s. A bunch of questions, and they started asking again in 1978. The kind of competing one is the Consumer Confidence Index, which is released by the Conference Board. They're asking about different things. The Consumer Sentiment Index is based on five questions on how you feel about the economy, business conditions. The confidence index is asking about a wider swath of things like, do you plan on going on vacation? So they're going to ask about a bunch of stuff, and then they're going to compile some of those into an index. And consumer confidence just has a ask about different things. And economists tend to favor the sentiment index because it's a little bit more focused on the economy and not necessarily like your plans.

Robin: What makes something an index?

Kathryn: So the idea of an index is that it's taking survey responses or it's taking multiple things and compiling them into a single number. Like the Consumer Price Index.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: Is. Is a kind of like a weighted average of a bunch of prices to come up with one number to describe price growth in the economy. It's an index meaning that it takes on a set of values that it summarizes in one.

Robin: Got it.

Kathryn: Because think of it as, like, they want to measure confidence or sentiment, and then they want to ask questions to understand why it's going up or down, the reason why. You know, Robin Rauzi and I were thinking that we wanted to do something about the midterms, but we don't really talk about politics on the show unless we're, like, casually deriding an elected official that we're not naming. Or all of Congress.

Robin: I don't say. Or the House of Representatives.

Kathryn: Yeah. Broadly trashing elected officials for lack of good performance. We don't really talk about politics.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: But we thought, what's something that the optimist would like to hear about heading into the midterms? Is there any insight that the economy gives other than people don't like it? And we actually thought explaining people don't like it that it's. That actually might be something that y'all would like to hear more about?

Robin: So, I mean, ever since, I don't know, you know, the famous 1992 election, Bill Clinton's, you know, it's the Economy stupid. Actually, it wasn't Clinton. Right. It was James Carville. But people have looked at the economy to be the weather vane pointing in the direction of where voters are. And we've been at this kind of strange moment where what the big economic numbers are showing is sort of divorced from what we see in these surveys.

Kathryn: Yeah, there's been a fairly predictable relationship between the calculated sentiment index and large economic indicators. That is broken. Why did it break?

Robin: OK, we can get to that in a second. But let's talk a little bit about where we are first in these sentiment numbers. What are they saying right now? What are they showing us?

Kathryn: OK, so I'm going to talk about consumer sentiment, which is the Michigan one. The numbers right now are bad and not bad, like low. I mean, they've been recording this monthly since January 1978. So this means we've gone through like some pretty bad recessions. The '80s was terrible. The Great Recession, the pandemic. We've been through the savings and loan crisis. We've been through the financial crisis, the foreclosure crisis. We've had multiple stock bubbles. And the worst, worst Americans have ever felt about the economy since then is right now.

Robin: That's amazing. It's. Yeah, that's amazing.

Kathryn: So it's like. I could say the number. It doesn't matter. It's the worst.

Robin: Yeah, I was going to say, does the number. Yeah. What is like 40 something or something?

Kathryn: Eleventy. It does. It's like this is the worst. This is what makes this so interesting is that wherever we are in the economy in the past, for whatever reason, this is the worst that people feel right now.

Robin: Worse than. Worse than the pandemic.

Kathryn: Worse than the pandemic? Yes.

Robin: And worse than 2022. I mean, 2022 is inflation takes off. God, that's amazing. A year ago the number was 55.1. And in September 2026 it was 48.1, which is a pretty significant slide in 12 months.

Kathryn: So it always falls in recessions. And so at various points it hits very low numbers. So like the low of the early 1980s was around 50. The low of the '90s recession was around like 63 or 64. The low of the dot-com, we were actually riding pretty high. It was around 80. The low of the financial crisis was 55. The pandemic, not so bad. The low is around 70. And then during the 2022 and that the peak of inflation, it was around 50.

Robin: And it's now 48.1.

Kathryn: Yes. And it was 45 earlier this summer.

Robin: Oh, it's turned around. Yeah.

Kathryn: It wasn't 44.8, but like, we're doing it, baby. Yeah. This deterioration is horrible because the other way to think about it is that you can think about sentiment basically existing within a range where it falls and rises within a very kind of like, pretty predictable set. And, and then after Trump, there's no other way to put it, after Trump takes office, it just, it hits lows that we've never seen before. And it, it doesn't just hit a low. It breaks from the bound that has been in for almost 50 years. Like, we're in totally unprecedented territory for how terrible Americans feel about the economy.

Robin: And the other thing that's interesting to me about the index of consumer sentiment is it's generally forward looking, right?

Kathryn: Yes. Oh, do you want me to give it to you?

Robin: So it's not, it's not. Yeah, give it to me. So it's because it's not like, how do you feel right now? What did you buy this month? It's very different from government statistics about consumer expenditures and price indexes and stuff. It's really like, where do you think this is going and how do you feel about that? Right?

Kathryn: Yes.

Robin: All right, hit me with, hit me with the question.

Kathryn: The questions. OK, one, would you say that you and your family living with you are better off or worse off financially than you were a year ago? And they can say better than a year ago, same or worse than a year ago. What makes Michigan very interesting is they ask after this to say, list all your reasons.

Robin: Oh, just sort of open ended.

Kathryn: So they include an open-ended question.

Robin: My husband lost his job.

Kathryn: Yep. OK. So question one is about today versus a year ago. Question two. Now, looking ahead, do you think that a year from now you and your family will be better off financially or worse off, or just the same as now.

Robin: OK.

Kathryn: And they're specific to say family living with you. Not family like your extended family, just family living with you.

Robin: So it's your household. Right.

Kathryn: So benchmark from one year ago, prediction for one year ahead. OK. All right, question three. Now turning to business conditions in the country as a whole. Do you think that during the next 12 months we'll have good times financially, bad times, or what?

Robin: Or what?

Kathryn: Or what? The answers are good times financially, partly good, partly bad, or bad times financially? Okay, question four. Looking ahead, which would you say is more likely that the country as a whole will have continuous good times during the next five years or that we will have periods of widespread unemployment or depression or what? Okay, last question about the big things people buy for their homes, such as furniture, refrigerator, stove, television, things like that. Generally speaking, do you think now is a good or bad time for people to buy a major household item, which could be kind of a combination question. Right. How's your. Can you afford it? How much does it cost? It's trying to ask about whether or not you think it's a good time to buy, but not necessarily trying to get at your capability for buying.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: So all five components, which you can look at the data separately, all five have greatly deteriorated.

Robin: So these five questions get added up or the results and that becomes the index.

Kathryn: That becomes the index.

Robin: We get it as a single number, but they can tease it out and look at what's happening on each of these.

Kathryn: Yeah, you can download the data and look at it yourself to see which one has had the biggest decline. They've all had pretty dramatic declines, I'd say. Maybe the buying conditions looks like, if you're just eyeballing it, the buying conditions look the worst. But each component has hit their series ever low since this summer.

Robin: That's amazing.

Kathryn: So it's not like there's just one that's like one is really bad, but everything else is like, kind of normal. Like, they've all hit the lowest they've ever recorded since April or May of this year.

Robin: This is Optimist Economy. And the other thing that I just wanted to note is that when the president first was inaugurated, it actually did go up these things for several months before cratering. And it started to crater around the announcement of the tariffs.

Kathryn: Yes. So what's really interesting to me about this is that there are people who are rejecting the data, and they're like, this data is wrong.

Robin: The consumer sentiment data.

Kathryn: Yeah, like the consumer sentiment data is wrong. And then there are people who are saying the people are wrong.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: They don't know what they're talking about. And then there are people who. Who are saying, I think the people have a pretty good handle on what's going on and the data are wrong. People have far too many people in the camp. But the survey switched from exclusively phone to web. And the kind of. The detractors of the survey will say, oh, it's because they changed their methodology. If you actually dig into the data and look at the various components and watch it over time, there are two really distinct deteriorations in sentiment. One of them is when the tariffs were announced in April of last year. Right, right.

Robin: This.

Kathryn: What was it called? It wasn't Judgment Day. It's called something else.

Robin: It was dumb Liberation Day.

Kathryn: Liberation Day, yeah. So right around Liberation Day when there's news stories on every outlet about how prices are going to go up because of tariffs and they announced them being like 40%. Yeah, 40% tariffs on everybody and we're going to trade war with Canada. That incredibly influenced people's opinion about whether or not they were going to be financially better off in a year. Sure, not surprising, not surprising. The other deterioration was after the war in Iran where like by April the sentiment was we are going to have much higher prices for a year. And actually the person who runs this survey pointed out that if you look at predictions of inflation coming from like central banks and coming from various markets, and here's what stock market or here's what various investment banks say, the Consumer Sentiment Index has correctly predicted inflation. Meaning that people have a better sense that prices will go up than kind of like oh well, if you assume that like you know, oil prices will spike for this long or like the pass through of tariffs will be at this rate, like people saying like, yeah, prices are going to be higher in a year. They got it.

Robin: They were closer than the wisdom of the crowds in there. I'm sure they don't ask exactly how much they think it's going to go up. Like that'd be like a really specific ask.

Kathryn: It's a long survey, not that long. But they ask things like no one can say for sure, but what do you think will happen to interest rates for borrowing money for the next 12 months? Will they go up, stay the same or go down?

Robin: But they don't say, what do you think the 10-year T-note will be trading?

Kathryn: They're not like what's the yield going to go up? So the other reason why I thought that this was so fascinating is that one of the questions. So zooming back out, the University of Michigan puts out this survey of consumers and five of the questions are used to compile the Consumer Sentiment Index. But the survey has lots of questions that aren't just those five. And one of those other questions asks specifically as to the economic policy of the government. I mean steps taken to fight inflation or unemployment. Would you say the government is doing a good job, only fair or a poor job?

Robin: I mean it sounds specifically targeted at the Fed, this question, but uh huh, yeah, yeah.

Kathryn: So this number is like I didn't believe it when I saw it because it's so bad. So the average between 1978 and 2024, including the back half of the Biden administration still coming off this high inflation. The poor job averaged around 31% over that period, and it's at 75% right now.

Robin: Wow. Yeah. So 75% of the people taking this survey think the government is doing a poor job of managing the economy.

Kathryn: Yeah.

Robin: Well, that must make you feel validated, because you've been saying that for years.

Kathryn: Yeah.

Robin: People are catching up to you, Kathryn.

Kathryn: But you know what's really interesting is that the three responses. Right. Good, fair, poor. It kind of says something about Americans that for almost all of the '80s and '90s, fair is about half.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: It's like people switch between good and poor based on whether or not we're in a recession. So it's like, oh, we're not in a recession, you're doing good. We're in a recession, poor. Right. But the amount that say fair, it's like about 50%. And then starting in the 2000s, and really right around the financial crisis, your average American used to say the government would do a fair job. And that starts about a decade and a half decline. And it's just a very persistent deterioration of economic policy views. And now that kind of enters this pressure cooker where we have a president making just absolutely obvious to everyone bad decisions about the economy. This disapproval rating goes up. And so I think, to me, it kind of captures that Americans are wise to the fact that our basic economic conditions are deteriorating through economic mismanagement. And this is a particularly mismanaged time. But you can't — it's not like everything was perfect leading into this. I mean, Americans have been getting sour on the government's handling of the economy basically since the financial crisis.

Robin: Yeah. Yeah. OK, so the financial crisis is 2008. But do we know anything about how consumer sentiment has tracked with elections? Like, is there a reason that people say it's the economy, stupid? Is it really?

Kathryn: Well, okay, so I will say elections tend to. When the economy had people lose.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: And as the economy is going south, presidents lose. So we brought this up. I don't understand which episode where we said that Trump is, like, one of three presidents who has come to office not in a recession.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: I think it's H.W., Dubya and Trump. They're like the three presidents that were elected during a good economy.

Robin: Both Bushes got good economies.

Kathryn: Both Bushes got a good economy because it's '89. We didn't have a recession until '90 or '91. I forget which year that one is. '91. That is the. It's the economy, stupid recession that then sweeps in Clinton. Bush wins in 2000. He's inaugurated in January of '01. The economy enters a recession in March of that year. So he's elected during a very good economy, and then a bad one kind of arrives on his doorstep. And then Trump in '17 and '25, both of those were like economies that were recovering from a bad time. We can't obviously blame him for the pandemic recession, but whatever's going on now, hundo P. On him. Hundo P. Hundo P. Bad stuff. Because Trump, and I'm a Ph.D., folks. Yeah. He's got a particularly sabotaging brand of economic policy, and Americans are wise to it.

Robin: Yeah. And it keeps compounding. Right. I think with that question in particular about would you say the government is doing a good job only for a poor job? You just see this sort of stair stepping down and things might, might bounce back a little bit and then. But each step is lower and lower and lower.

Kathryn: I'm so fascinated with this secular decline in thinking the government is doing a good job on economic policy that's almost 20 years old and that it's been eroding for a while. Wait, we have to do a quick sidebar on politics.

Robin: Yeah. I was just thinking, we didn't really mention. I mean, these things do track a lot with whether your party preference is in the White House or in political power. Right.

Kathryn: Yes. And they cancel each other out.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: So, like, Republicans feel bad when Democrats are in power and Democrats feel bad when Republicans are in power. But the thing about the average is that they switch. So you, so you can say that like, oh, well, some people don't like the economy because it's a Republican, but other people will like the economy because it's a Republican. And so the survey itself is not biased towards one political party, even though political bias shows up. I mean, the country's about like, like 50-50.

Robin: But they also look at independents. Right. So they'll say this is where Republicans are, this is where Democrats are. But when you look at independents, you know, they, they track with the average, maybe, and they're actually a little bit lower than the average.

Kathryn: Yes.

Robin: The, the independents feel the, feel kind of the worst.

Kathryn: And what's remarkable about the past, I would say, six months is the deterioration amongst Republicans.

Robin: Right.

Kathryn: And that the typical good feeling that Republicans have of having Republicans in charge is. I don't know. To me, the timing looks pretty clear around Iran and oil prices. That's kind of a part of the big change is not that Democrats feel bad. I mean, they were not happy.

Robin: No.

Kathryn: This whole time, but it's really Republicans feeling worse. That was a sidebar. So it's not just politics that explains sentiment because we as a country cancel each other out.

Robin: Yeah. OK, so. So where does this leave us? Like, everybody feels bad. Their bad sentiment is moving in conjunction with real world events. They're not happy about what the government's doing in response.

Kathryn: OK. One of the reasons why I wanted to bring it up was because this is going to be presented as the same thing happened to Biden.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: Where like, the Biden officials were saying that the economy was good and.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: But people didn't feel good. And so they were just like, it's. Well, we're just doing like Republicans and Trump are just doing what Biden and the Democrats did in '24. But really the numbers aren't the same and the experience isn't the same. The Biden negative sentiment was price growth had fallen, but prices had not and people were mad. What's happening now just two years later is you were doing a bad job managing the economy and these policies are hurting us. I think, to me, they're pretty different in a really interesting way, I suppose, because the opportunity for what comes next is different.

Robin: What do you mean?

Kathryn: We think about the economy so often in the way that it's discussed in the news of, like, prices are doing this. What should the Fed do? Right. Unemployment is doing this. What should the Fed do? We always talk about it as how we need to react to what the economy is doing. But I think it's time to be pro, like, this is a clear case for me to be proactive that people desperately want something different from our economy. If you needed to make the case that Americans are ready for something different, like, I would hand them this data.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: And it's not about like, oh, well, they just say affordable, but like, it's because they have phones and they don't care. Like, you know, like, you just, you take any aspect of the affordability crisis and you wave it away and you, you are like, well, they just want to buy houses, but like, they didn't save enough or like, they want bigger houses than they can afford. Like, you, you. There's a way to like, minimize and erase the feelings of people when they tell you they can't afford things. But I find this data to be just so incredible and that it's a very specific measurement of mood that has collapsed.

Robin: Right. And it's across all these questions.

Kathryn: It's across all these questions. And if you needed this, like, clench your fist and like, if you're driving, kind of like, punch the steering wheel. Like, guys.

Robin: God.

Kathryn: The people who still feel good about the economy own a lot of stock.

Robin: Yeah.

Kathryn: Like, people who own a lot of stock, feeling great. Like, they're great. They're fine. It's really like, if you separate Americans by people who own stock or own a lot of stock versus people who don't, there's a massive sentiment gap, and that's a larger gap than you would see by age or by income, is really about stock wealth. So, I mean, if you ever needed an argument to radically change how we organize our economy, I feel like this data is here to say we're ready.

Robin: Yeah. So the optimism out of all this for you is that Americans are ready for change, eager for it.

Kathryn: Yeah. We talk about a lot of things on this show. We talk about big swing policies that are very different from how we've done things, which over the past 25 years, I would characterize as doing very little at all. But, you know, you get this. Like, you're not allowed to do that. That's too dramatic. There are people who will tell you the only type of change that's possible is incremental. And I just think that this souring of the mood on the economy, both secular and acute, is a real argument for not being incremental. And I think I would have a harder time convincing people we need to, like, radically change health insurance or childcare if, like, sentiment numbers and economic policy numbers were coming in in, like, the high 80s. Like, oh, man, we're doing great. Like, everybody's really happy. Yeah. I mean, like, why do you need to have dramatic, like, bold policy if most people are doing great? Like, they. You know, they don't. I mean, people at the bottom have always been having a hard time, but most people are doing great and they feel good about their own situation. So, like, why do we need to restructure this thing? But now you see this lack of almost faith in the U.S. economy and its stewardship, and it's like, yeah, yeah, we need to do, like, pull out the big guns. Nothing incremental.

Robin: We need to.

Kathryn: We need to do some stuff to help. And. And it's not just because, like, this is the opportunity that low sentiment gives us. Like, this is what low sentiment deserves. Like, the American people are telling us they're miserable. Like, this is what they deserve in response. Not like, it's just this opportunism of like, oh, people feel. Let's do something. Like, no, I mean, it's like people feel like, let's help them. And that help can't be small. It should be big. Or hear me out. A middling midterms. But no, I think we could go big. I think we could go big.

Robin: Great. Great. All right, we're going to take a break, and then we'll be back with executive orders and spiritual sponsors. Okay, we're back for executive orders. Kathryn. I'm going to do mine really quickly because you have a lot.

Kathryn: Executive orders for our newer listeners are ways, mainly petty, that we fix the world. Petty and small. Not always petty, but sometimes. But most.

Robin: Not always small. Sometimes big. Anyway, I was on vacation. Hat tip to Seinfeld here. If you reserve a car, it would be nice if there's actually the car there that you have reserved, not a minivan.

Kathryn: Wait, did you have a minivan?

Robin: No, I managed to get into a different car, which was not great. Great. But it was not also. Also not the car I had reserved.

Kathryn: That's only once worked out in my favor where they're like, we don't have your car. So take this real badass one we have instead. That happened to me once, and it was amazing. And otherwise, it's like, here's the. The dumpier, smaller version.

Robin: Yeah, once that happened to me, and it was like, here, take this Dodge Durango, which I live on a really tiny street. It was impossible to park. It was a disaster. It was just terrible. Anyway, no, this time I got the world's most basic Toyota Corolla. If you don't actually rent a hybrid car at your location, don't take reservations for it. What are your executive orders, Kathryn?

Kathryn: I just have a few. One of them is that liability waivers need to be 70% to 80% more chill.

Robin: They're terrifying.

Kathryn: It's just a really terrifying list of things to come out. And I'm like, you shouldn't actually be free of this liability. I should not be able to waive away all of these liabilities. Clearly, you were responsible for this. So new regime of liability waivers. Maybe a Likert scale of, like, how much can you sue? A lot? A little bit? Not so much. None at all. I need four types of suing people for liability, and you need to tell me which land I live in. But, like, yeah, I should be able to sue a couple of places. And that liability waiver was insane. Okay, second executive order is we need fewer types of eggs.

Robin: You mean like, like in the grocery store eggs?

Kathryn: Yeah. Cause there's way too many options.

Robin: Like, that's true. Yeah. It's just.

Kathryn: I mean, like, I don't even know what I'm looking at.

Robin: Organic, cage free. Organic cage free, brown, you know, pasture raised.

Kathryn: I mean, I counted there were, like, 16 different types of separately types of eggs that you could buy at the store. And I was like, this is untenable. We need fewer egg types. That's an executive order.

Robin: Okay.

Kathryn: Final executive order. You aren't allowed to say to parents, your kids have so many toys. I think either you need to say your kids are poorly behaved or you're a shitty parent. Your kids have so many toys is not interpretable as is. Or just say, wow, you're rich. Like, give me the actual thing you're saying. Your kids are poorly behaved. You have a lot of money. You spoil your kids. One of those. But your kids have so many toys is a statement that I don't know how to respond to.

Robin: Maybe it's. You need to learn to purge and throw some things away.

Kathryn: Yeah, then just say that. I mean, just. Just saying, like, wow, look at all these toys. I'm like, okay. I'm like, yeah, we do. Well, I don't know. What am I supposed to say here?

Robin: Children love toys. We have several children.

Kathryn: Okay, I'm gonna move to a shack by the river and put them to work, so you won't judge me for being a bad modern parent. All right. If they're.

Robin: If they're foraging, go chain daisies.

Kathryn: Like, yeah, we did. I guess if they were delivering paper routes or something. Whatever y'all hearken onto. But it's a very. It's such an attack on modern parenthood to both judge parents for having their kids on screens and then equally judge them for having screen substitutes, AKA toys and books in your house and be like, wow, that's a lot of. That's a lot of toys. That's a lot of toys. Okay, let's go into spiritual sponsors and wait, anchor for the new listeners. We don't have actual financial sponsors for the show. Many of our listeners, we're open to that. We are open. I mean, if anyone has a lot of money and wants to give it to us. Robin and I are actually quite chill. Of course, we won't do what you say or say what you want us to, but we will take your money. We have many listeners who give support to the show, without which we would not be able to make it. But we don't have that kind of, like, big money sponsorship ad where I start talking to you about, like, sheets or something or pillows? We don't have any of those people, listeners. We have you, the spiritual sponsors, the things that keep us going. Robin, what are your spiritual sponsors?

Robin: Okay, this is gonna start like a bummer, but about the time we went on break, there was a horrifying fire in Spokane, Washington, which was my home for two and a half years, just before we started doing this podcast. And many friends evacuated for weeks. Fortunately, I'm lucky that nobody I know immediately lost their house, but 600 houses were lost in that fire, and it came right up to the edge of town or came into town anyway. I still follow the news from Spokane, and it was heartwarming to see the ways that the people of that city came together to help one another. And I also specifically wanted to shout out the Worthy family, whose name is, in fact, Worthy, who don't even, I think, live there anymore, but had a very famous historic hotel in downtown, who gave $10,000 to every person who lost their house or their apartment in that fire. So well done, Spokane. And finally, in our ever growing category of friends with friends with swimming pools, friends with trucks, I'm going to add friends with apartments in New York City.

Kathryn: God, that really is lucky. That's what the best.

Robin: Okay, over to you.

Kathryn: You know, this was a break in which I was notionally trying to write the book that I'm under.

Robin: You were trying to write.

Kathryn: It was. I had, like. I had a real tough time starting out and figuring out how I wanted to say it. I had to give myself permission to say things. You know, I'm not writing, like, a romance novel, but I feel like there was so much emotion and, like, struggle that went into just, like, trying to write down the things that we say here. And then actually a genuinely insane amount of child illnesses that sidelined my production for. Honestly, the whole month of August was. Was, like, basically lost to a rotating set of illnesses. So setbacks, insecurities, crises of confidence, and then I moved forward. And so I have lots of spiritual sponsors to thank who got me over that hump. The first one's gonna start bad. But on the first day of school, as I was walking my child to the first day, you know, holding their hand, I was wearing a shirt that said, the whole world watches women's sports in French. And some piece of human being, older guy walking with his wife, I presume, looked at me holding my child's hand, I mean, 10 feet from an elementary school on the first day of school, and said, really, the whole world, as I was walking by. It took me a minute to. I was like, what did he. He just made fun of me. I'm wearing a shirt that says the whole world watches women's sports. And he just made fun of me about that in front of my child, walking my child to school. So. So my first spiritual sponsor is any bird that has pooped on his car, any dog that has pooped that he has walked into on accident. Maybe someone rear-ended him once and hurt what I assumed to be a nice car. That'd be great. Anytime his sports team has lost. And it was really heartbreaking for him. That's also part of my sponsoredness. Just really anytime the world gave that guy a slap in the face, the way he gave me a slap in the face on an otherwise really. So karma, yeah, whatever. Bad karma, that's not catastrophic, but just a little bit that hit that guy. That's my first spiritual sponsor. OK. Coffee, obviously, is just perennial spiritual sponsor. Shout it out. Good. Star Trek episodes. The book "The Wedding People." Cousin hangs. So amazing. Hanging out with cousins when you're an adult, you're like, oh, you're just friends I get to have without trying. It's amazing. Oh, spiritual sponsor. Finding other chill parents. This is so important, and it's awesome. I don't know if this happens in L.A., but in Houston at bars, especially at patio bars, there's a guy who walks around with a backpack selling hot tamales, and you just buy the tamales off of him. The tamale guy. It's very similar to the hot dog guy that follows Homer Simpson around. Seeing a group of 30 children trying to dance the Cha Cha Slide.

Robin: That's my spiritual sponsor. I didn't even see it.

Kathryn: Yeah, the movie "A League of Their Own," which I recently rewatched on a plane. No notes. That movie is so good. And then people who understand sarcasm on TikTok and Instagram, especially when I say, here's me being sarcastic and then say something I didn't realize. Sarcasm is like a.

Robin: It's a dying art.

Kathryn: It's a dying art. So all of that helped me so much over these two months, as did, of course, the encouragement that we got from Optimist in various ways over those two months. We were very excited to be back recording. And the book is not done, but it will be, but it's getting done. Optimist Economy Podcast is edited by Sofi LaLonde and our video production for social media is by Andy Robinson. Without the two of them, the show would not be possible. Video clips from the show for you to share are available on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn. T-shirts. New set of hats. We reordered some more hats, so we have some. And tote bags are available on our website optimisteconomy.com.

Robin: If you're on Substack as a free or paid subscriber to Optimist Economy, you can join our chat room. And if you have the means to contribute at whatever level is comfortable for you, we will gladly take that gift at optimisteconomy.com.

Robin: And I think. I'm sorry I said that the independents are the worst. They're not. That isn't quite what I meant to say.

Kathryn: No, they are the worst. They're just like, totally the worst. Just join a party, man. Be a joiner.

Donate